The Best Mattresses for Couples, Tested by Experts

If you're looking for a comfortable mattress that can suit differing sleep positions and individual preferences, this one's your best bet. It's a hybrid model that layers foam over coils and has a true medium feel — i.e., not too soft and not too firm. It also has a built-in pillowtop for extra comfort, which is a nice touch that you don't see on most boxed beds.

The mattress ships in a box for DIY setup. It's quite heavy (which is expected given its tall height and layered construction), and it doesn't have any handles on the side, so you'll likely need two people for the unboxing. And while this is the Dusk Luxe model, the brand also has a Dusk version without the "Luxe," meaning there are fewer layers for a lower price.

TESTER NOTES: Real couples gave it top marks — including for comfort and overall sleep quality — and highlighted how well it satisfied their unique needs. A tester told us, "It's a good mix for me (a side sleeper) and my partner (a back sleeper)," while other users confirmed it offered good support regardless of whether they were sleeping on their stomachs, backs or sides.

Our reviewers also raved about the pressure relief, saying it conformed nicely to their bodies without too much sinking in. Most also found it to have good motion isolation, though one tester said they did feel movement if their partner was too close in the bed.

This Tuft & Needle mattress is less than half the price of other top picks for couples but still delivers on important aspects like motion isolation and comfort for various sleep positions. Its simple construction is made of two layers of foam — a supportive layer on the bottom with a more breathable one on top — and has a fairly firm feel for a foam bed.

Another perk: Because it's sold on Amazon, it ships quickly and can arrive at your house in days. We've seen a lot of frustration with mattress delivery delays and the hassles of scheduling during our reviews, but the reliability and standout feedback make this our pick for the best mattress on Amazon.

TESTER NOTES: It's been highly rated by our reviewers for years despite its lower cost. In fact, users give it high scores for everything from ease of ordering and setup to comfort and support during use. Several highlighted the motion isolation, saying they couldn't feel movements from their sleeping partners. One even told us, "My Tuft & Needle mattress is so much more comfortable than any mattress I've ever had in the past. My husband and I both experience much less back pain."

The main complaint from testers was the lack of edge support, meaning the bed may sag when you sit on the sides. On the plus side, they raved about the brand's customer service, saying the representatives were extremely helpful.

Saatva's mattress is ideal for couples that prefer a traditional, responsive bed over the sinking-in feel of foam. The inside is primarily made up of two layers of coils. Though innersprings typically aren't as good at preventing motion transfer, Saatva's top layer of springs uses pocketed coils, which helps reduce this effect. The mattress comes in three firmness levels with Luxury Firm being the most popular and closest to a true medium feel.

This one also stands out for its included in-home setup and old mattress removal. While many online mattress brands ship their models compressed in a box for DIY setup, this one can't be rolled up, and your purchase includes White Glove delivery.

TESTER NOTES: More than 100 owners of this model gave it glowing reviews in our survey. Several described it as an excellent balance with comments like, "firm, but not hard" and "comfortable and just the right amount of plush." They also found it to feel more breathable and cool than memory foam mattresses. On top of that, they loved the convenience of the in-home setup.

READ OUR FULL REVIEW: Experts Share Why Saatva is the Best Innerspring Mattress

Memory foam beds create the best motion isolation, and Tempur-Pedic's mattresses are superior in this aspect. Though most of the brand's models cost several thousand dollars, the Tempur-Cloud is the brand's boxed model that gives you the same popular foam at a more affordable price. It uses three layers of pressure-relieving foam and has a medium feel to suit most preferences and sleep positions.

Because of how well it conforms to your body, this mattress is especially good for side sleepers because it takes the weight off of your shoulders and hips while keeping you aligned. It may feel firm when you first lie down, but it slowly adapts to your shape.

TESTING NOTES: It earned high marks for comfort, support and overall sleep quality from users. Couples especially liked the feel, with one telling us, "We were delighted with the comfort. The foam is lovely if you like that feeling of sinking into a warm hug when you sleep. We can’t deny that we slept well on this mattress."

Another user said, "I feel like my entire body is supported in a very gentle way." Our reviewers also note that the mattress holds up well over time, making it worth the investment. One even compared it to past beds and said, "It was definitely a major upgrade."

READ OUR FULL REVIEW: Tempur-Pedic's Tempur-Cloud Mattress is The Most Luxurious Bed in a Box

If back discomfort affects one or both sleeping partners, this model checks off the boxes for an ideal mattress for back pain: Medium firmness and memory foam for pressure relief. Beyond that, real testers told us it improved or got rid of their pain. It's made up of three layers of foam with dense support foam on the bottom and plusher foam on top for cradling comfort.

It's also a good value thanks in part to its all-foam construction, though the 10-inch height is on the lower side. Also, note that this mattress is specifically marketed toward side sleepers (which happens to be the recommended sleep position for back pain sufferers).

TESTING NOTES: Users consistently tell us it relieves their discomfort. One reviewer said, "It offers back support while still cradling pressure points. It has been significantly helpful in relieving back pain for my husband, who has scoliosis." Beyond that, a tester of the hybrid version of this mattress said, "On the first day of testing, I went to bed with a strained back from hours of sitting at my desk. When I woke up the next day, the pain was completely gone."

Beyond back pain relief, the durability and cooling aspects stood out to our panel. One owner that's had it for four years raved about how well it kept its shape, while other users told us that it felt cool — a huge feat for a foam mattress.

One of the most complicated situations while mattress shopping for couples is when the two individuals have a significant difference in body weight. While there are mattresses designed for heavier bodies, these models may feel too firm and uncomfortable to the sleeping partner with a lighter weight. Purple's innovative construction is a great option in this case because it can accommodate heavier weights and has a firm yet squishy surface that feels good for varying body types.

The top layer consists of the brand's GelFlex Grid, which is essentially an elastic grid. As an added bonus, the open construction is breathable and cool to sleep on. The brand says it's recommended for up to 300 pounds per side or 600 pounds total. Beyond that, this model offers excellent motion isolation.

TESTING NOTES: It satisfied a wide range of preferences in our testing and users confirmed the motion isolation works well, saying they couldn't feel their sleeping partners move throughout the night. They especially loved the unique feel, noting it was the perfect balance of soft and firm. Users told us it feels like "sleeping on air" and "like floating in every position." One added, "It's 'springy' and conforms to my body while still being supported." Just note that several users told us they experienced shipping delays when buying this mattress.

Bedgear's model uses a genius modular design that allows couples with distinctly different needs to share a mattress, thanks to the fact that each side has its own separate fill. There are four firmness levels to choose from for each side, and they're interchangeable so you can swap them out over time and buy a new one if your needs change.

The fill is a hybrid, with coils on the bottom and foam on top to help prevent motion transfer. And because the mattress is modular, it can come apart into several pieces for easier setup.

TESTING NOTES: We haven't received as much user feedback on this model through our consumer surveys (likely because of its higher price and rare design), but we were impressed with its construction, and testers that have used it swear by it. Users especially like the swappable option, and one tester called it the "mattress of the future." She also said, "I like that this mattress has such a high-end feel with customization but the convenience of at-home purchase and set-up. I love that I could potentially customize it to be softer or harder in the future."

Though this model doesn't have any specific features that cater to couples, it's our pick for the best hybrid mattress and has blown away real tester couples with its comfort. It's a hybrid made up of a cushioned top, several layers of foam and a layer of coils on the bottom, making it an impressive 14 inches tall.

The construction also offers ergonomic support with zoned sections that vary in firmness to help keep your spine aligned. Just note that although its website boasts "environmentally-friendly materials" and natural minerals to promote recovery, we couldn't validate these claims in our review process.

TESTING NOTES: Couples told us they got better, more uninterrupted sleep after testing this mattress. They also gave it perfect scores across the board, and one even called it "the most comfortable mattress we have ever slept on." She also said it was a perfect fit for both her and her husband and added, "This is undoubtedly the best mattress we have ever owned. We have traveled all over and have never had the sleep experience we now have every night."

Though this mattress is pricier than others, it's made of GOTS-certified organic materials and has a modular design that makes it perfect for couples. There are five firmness options for each side, and the brand even gives you 100 days to exchange your firmness level at no charge if it's not a good fit.

The fill is a combination of latex, wool and coils, all encased in a cotton cover. Plus, its easy-access zipper makes it simpler to set up the mattress and replace the inner layers as needed.

TESTER NOTES: Besides the ability to customize each side, testers loved the motion isolation created by the separate fills and said they couldn't feel their sleeping partners move around. One summarized her experience by saying, "It's very comfortable and supportive. I love that it's organic, and I'm not sleeping on a bed of chemicals!"

Unlike modular designs that let you choose your firmness when you buy, this smart mattress lets you customize your firmness level in real time. It's perfect for couples that don't agree on firmness, but it's also ideal for being able to change the feel as your needs evolve. Beyond that, it has biometric sensors that detect if you switch positions so it can automatically adjust and keep you at your preferred firmness level.

It's made up of air chambers that allow for adjustability, plus there's a 5-inch foam layer for pressure relief on top. This bed also has built-in sleep trackers that give you feedback on your sleep performance. Note that the full-service delivery costs an extra $249, but it includes in-home assembly, mattress removal and technician support to walk you through how the bed works.

TESTER NOTES: Our testers and more than 300 Sleep Number owners on our panel gave their mattress top scores for comfort, support and sleep quality. They also said it holds up well; users that have owned it for 10 years said it was a worthy investment. One Sleep Number owner said, "I was initially hesitant because of the cost, but as soon as I laid on it, it changed my mind." Another told us, “I really feel like it gives me a custom sleep experience"