Our Editors Tried the Viral Amazon Dresses Everyone’s Talking About

Editor impressions:

• It looks way more expensive than it is. The matching shrug truly takes it to the next level—I love how it adds extra warmth without taking away from the silhouette.

Fit:

• I'm in between sizes and prefer a fitted look, so I sized down. The dress is stretchy, but I'd recommend sizing up if you prefer a baggier fit.

Fabric feel:

• I appreciate that the fabric is thick and form-fitting without revealing every lump and bump.

Editor impressions:

• "I felt confident and comfortable in this dress—two priorities when I'm shopping for a new outfit," says Senior Editor Amanda Fama. "The colors are also perfect for autumn! I really love that it's easy to wear the sleeves off the shoulder. Overall, I'd definitely buy this dress in other colors."

Fit:

• "True to size; it fit perfectly. The skirt length is perfect for high-top boots. The top half is stretchy and the skirt is a nice length."

Fabric feel:

• "The fabric is lightweight. I get warm super easily—and even with long sleeves, I felt comfortable throughout the entire duration of wearing it."

Editor impressions:

• "While it wasn’t a perfect fit for me, it’s comfortable and extremely versatile for various seasons and occasions," says Deputy Managing Editor Cristina Corvino.

Fit:

• "I'm generally between an extra-small and small in dresses, and the small was big around my chest (especially while sitting) and the sleeve elastic didn’t hug my wrists."

Fabric feel:

• "Though not very thick, it wasn’t see-through in the color I tried (but it could be in lighter colors)."

Editor impressions:

• "I was pleasantly impressed by the softness of this piece," says Commerce Content Strategy Manager Sophie Park. "The length falls right around mid knee, which makes it versatile to pair with sneakers or boots."

Fit:

• "The sizing is fairly accurate. I’m 5'3", and while the dress does have an oversized look, it’s not so big that it feels unflattering."

Fabric feel:

• "The fabric is thick and cozy—perfect for fall weather. I did notice some pilling when a hanger snagged on the knit portions."

Editor impressions:

• "This off-shoulder dress with ruffle detailing is perfect for fall," says Commerce Editor Anvita Reddy. "The skirt is whimsically flowy with its tiered skirt and high-leg slit. I also appreciate the elasticated waistband, which gives me a more fitted, shapely look, while the layered fabric at the bust and skirt make me look taller."

Fit:

• "I'm traditionally a size small (5'1" with a bigger bust) and this was a near-perfect fit for me. The only place where I felt I could alter is the armhole portion to make it slightly tighter."
  

Fabric feel:

• "The fabric is a bit thin, but it was lined in areas that needed it so I did not feel overexposed in any way. [It's] soft on the skin, lightweight, and doesn't have much stretch to it."